Gluten Free / Main Course / Pies and Pastry / Potato / Tofu / Vegan / Vegan MoFo

Vegan ‘Fish’ Pie with Tofu and Oyster Mushroom – Vegan MoFo


No Sealife were harmed in the making of this pie!

This is literally my new favourite recipe! The UK is an Island with so many amazing beach towns, fisheries and ports so recipes such as Fish pie and Fish and Chips were always going to be included in a “British Classics” round up. I was born in Devon and go back every now and then to see family and visit the town and beaches; some of my favourite memories (actually most of them) include eating chips whilst sat on deck chairs (in the winter wrapped up in woolly snow gear!) or on the beach wall and being absolutely ambushed by seagulls!

Seagulls are relentless once they spot food and I swear they are getting bigger! We were once sat on the beach sharing a bag of chips and this huge seagull flew down and stood about a foot away from me, every time I blinked he’d edged forward and eventually he stole the chip from my hand and flew off celebrating with loud squawks and shrill laughter.


The picture of comfort!

Along with a lot of other traditional British recipes this dish is great for using up leftovers, however this dish doesn’t have such a complete peasant background. Fish became popular in the 16th century when the church banned all Christians from eating meat for nearly half a year (around 200 days) to remind them of Christ’s sacrifice and to provide a spiritual lesson in self restraint. Instead people of high and low status became creative with their fish recipes, trying to make them grand and celebration worthy.

I initially thought a vegan version of this classic dish would be quite difficult to create as it has quite a strong flavour and is very creamy with a thick sauce, however it was actually really simple! I followed the same principle of my cottage pie and cooked down the veg, then added flour, then the liquid (in this case dairy free milk instead of mushroom stock) and finally added the tofu last to keep it soft.

A good fish pie has different textures and flavours in it so I decided to add oyster mushrooms which are a bit chewy along side the soft tofu and al dente vegetables. Another quality of a good fish pie in my eyes is a thick layer of cheesy mash on top! This is easily recreated with vegan cheese πŸ™‚

Fish pie –
2 carrots
1 leek
1 onion
2 garlic
1 tblspn flour
1 gluten free vegetable stock cube
2 tblspn nutritional yeast
Salt and pepper
1 tspn paprika
500ml unsweetened non dairy milk (I used almond)
1/2 lemon juice
120g oyster mushrooms
1/4 nori sheet
200g tofu
50g peas
Small bunch parsley
600g potatoes mashed with
vegan cheese

To prepare your vegetables – finely chop the carrots, leeks and onion and crush the garlic. In a large saucepan or wide deep frying pan fry the vegetables in a little oil on a medium heat for 6-8 minutes until they are wilted.

Then add the flour, crumble in the stock cube, seasoning, nutritional yeast and paprika and give everything a good stir so it is all combined.

Add the milk and lemon juice, tear small pieces of the nori sheet off and add them with the sliced oyster mushrooms, tofu, peas and chopped parsley. Stir again and lower the heat to a gentle simmer and cook for a further 10 minutes.

Heat your oven to 180c.

Boil, drain and mash your potatoes then mix in a strong flavoured vegan cheese of your choice.

Pour the filling into a baking dish and then top with the mashed potato and bake in the oven for 30 minutes until the top is golden and the filling is bubbling away.


22 thoughts on “Vegan ‘Fish’ Pie with Tofu and Oyster Mushroom – Vegan MoFo

  1. Pingback: 30 Plant Based Recipes For Vegans Who Are Starting In November

  2. My name is Liz and I’m contacting you from Silver River Productions, a TV company based in London. We are currently in production for a BBC2 primetime gardening show β€˜The Big Allotment Challenge.’

    The series follows a handful of talented amateur kitchen gardeners as they transform a plot of earth in our walled garden into a patch of beauty and reveal all the wonderful possibilities that can be unlocked from allotment growing.

    We are looking for contestants to feature in the series, those who have the skill and dedication and who could dig their way to victory and be crowned the winner of β€˜The Big Allotment Challenge.’ People who can cultivate the perfect carrot, make their green tomatoes into tasty chutney and turn their dahlias and sweet peas into floral arrangements.

    So whether you’re an allotmenteer, a city living window box grower, or a gardening enthusiast, we want to hear from you. We are coming to the end of our application process so email for an application form today!

  3. I am so loving your blog posts, you have such a way of sharing your stories, I honestly and looking at the UK with fresh eyes. Your UK posts would make a lovely, story bound, vegan cookbook. Thank you for sharing!

    • Thanks, I got the dish from a little pottery gallery in south of France, this couple had a small business making them and it was all really amazing! My mum let me choose a couple of dishes as a Christmas present last year πŸ™‚

  4. This looks amazing…it looks like something that you could take home to mother and get her approval with…no meat but mum approved…what more could you want! Steve is going to LOVE this :). Sometimes he misses good old U.K. comfort food like fish pie. He hates killing fish though so when he goes “fishing” he just pootles around in his boat (the Mumbly Cumumbus) on the river and lets any fish that he catches go free so this is the PERFECT recipe for him πŸ™‚

I love hearing what you all have to say!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s